City issues demolition and residential permits for former church site near UD

A family intends to build a new home there, attorney says
Fencing was being placed around the former First Church of Christ, Scientist, in the South Dayton Rubicon residential neighborhood near the University of Dayton campus Tuesday. Dayton has issued a wrecking permit for the site. THOMAS GNAU/STAFF

Fencing was being placed around the former First Church of Christ, Scientist, in the South Dayton Rubicon residential neighborhood near the University of Dayton campus Tuesday. Dayton has issued a wrecking permit for the site. THOMAS GNAU/STAFF

The city of Dayton has issued a commercial wrecking permit for a former church property at 105 Sawmill Road, and the site is being fenced off in preparation for demolition and eventual construction of a new home there.

The Dayton Daily News reported in April that the University of Dayton’s real estate arm had transferred the former church in the South Dayton neighborhood to a university-created limited liability company (LLC).

According to the deed for the site, the property is not to be used for any purpose other than as an owner-occupied residence for 50 years. But that restriction does not prevent the owner from dividing the property into condominiums or “separate building lots.”

The city issued a wrecking permit for the property to Steve R. Rauch Inc. of West Carollton.

The city has also issued a residential permit for that address for a “two-story single residence with (a) basement.” The permit was issued to G.A. White Homes Inc., a Beavercreek custom home builder.

A local family has purchased the site with plans for a home there, Dayton attorney Natalie Rauf wrote to city government and the University of Dayton Tuesday.

“We understand there may be curiosity about the family’s plans for the property,” Rauf wrote. “The family intends to build a new residence on the property and they look forward to living in the city of Dayton and being a part of the local neighborhood. The exact timeline of the construction is not known at this time.”

The area at the northeast corner of Sawmill and Rubicon roads was being fenced off Tuesday morning. Warnings about asbestos were posted on the structure’s front doors.

The former church was being fenced off at 105 Sawmill Road in south Dayton Tuesday. The city of Dayton has issued a commercial wrecking permit for the site. THOMAS GNAU/STAFF

icon to expand image

The buyer and the seller in the two-parcel transaction back in April both had addresses that match the University of Dayton’s address, 300 College Park Drive. Records identified the buyer as 105 Sawmill LLC, and the seller as East Aqua Development, also an LLC.

According to property records, 105 Sawmill LLC is still the site’s owner.

The city’s wrecking permit identifies the site’s owner as East Aqua Development VI LLC, also at 300 College Park.

In April, a spokeswoman for the university said UD no longer owns the property.

However, Mary Ann P. Recker, vice president and general counsel at UD, signed the incorporation papers for the the creation of 105 Sawmill LLC, according to state filings. The LLC was created in March this year.

The transaction’s conveyance form showed that no money was exchanged for the property. The grantor and grantee — the “seller” and the “buyer” — are owned by the same parent entity, records showed.

The Montgomery County auditor’s office has not received conveyance paperwork for the property since that April transfer, a spokesman for the auditor’s office said.

Sometimes, an entity can create an limited liability company that owns property and then sell that LLC to a new owner, the spokesman said, but he added that he has no evidence that happened in this case. If that happens, the auditor’s office will have no record of it.

About the Author